Following bleach with an alcohol sanitiser
Doing both to be thorough is the reasoning, and the two react. Hypochlorite with alcohols forms chloroform.
What is claimed
That cleaning a surface with bleach and then going over it with an alcohol-based sanitiser or wipe gives more thorough disinfection than either product alone.
Where this comes from: Widely circulated online.
Does it work?
Does not work
A US state health department lists this among combinations not to make. Chloroform formation rests on one authoritative source. That is reason enough to rinse first, though it is not as well documented as the chlorine reactions.
Whether something is safe on a particular surface is a separate question, answered below.
Where not to use it
Stainless steel
Best avoided
The available guidance advises against this.
Beyond the reaction, hypochlorite's chloride content attacks the passive layer on stainless steel, and the trade association advises against leaving it in contact. A surface treated this way has had bleach on it for the whole time the second product was being applied.
Precautions
- Never mix with other cleaning products
- Ventilate the area
- Rinse thoroughly afterwards
- Keep away from children and pets
What actually happens
The claim assumes the two disinfectants act independently and additively, each killing what the other missed. Hypochlorite instead reacts with alcohols to produce chlorinated organic compounds including chloroform, and it does so without heating or unusual conditions. The reaction consumes both products, so the additive disinfection the technique is reaching for does not occur either. As with the acid reaction, the common route is sequential rather than simultaneous: the first product is applied, not rinsed, and the second goes onto the same wet surface — which is combining them, with the surface as the vessel.
Background
This is not a hack so much as a habit, and it became a common one: wipe a surface with bleach, then go over it with an alcohol sanitiser or wipe, on the assumption that two disinfectants are more thorough than one. Neither product is being mixed in the ordinary sense, and nobody performing it thinks of themselves as combining chemicals. A US state health department hazard alert nonetheless names the pair — bleach with rubbing alcohol forms chloroform, with reported effects of dizziness, nausea, headaches and loss of consciousness. Losing consciousness in the presence of the reaction that caused it is what makes this worse than the symptom list suggests, since the exposure continues while the person cannot leave. The practical point is that isopropyl alcohol is the active ingredient in a great many surface wipes and hand rubs, so you can do this without having seen the word alcohol on anything.
What it does not do
- One authoritative source states this hazard, on a list rather than as its main subject, and no second source states it
- Rinsing thoroughly between products removes the hazard, and is the answer wherever both are genuinely needed
- Disinfection requires a specified period of wet contact regardless, so a surface wiped and immediately dried has not been disinfected by either product
What to use instead
- Detergent — A surfactant-based cleaner. The general-purpose answer for greasy and particulate soil, and the correct first choice far more often than any specialist product.
- Rinsing and drying — The step people skip, and the one that decides whether cleaning protected the surface or damaged it. Residue left behind is exposure that continues after you stop.
Evidence
Does not work
Sources
Hazard Alert — Worker Health and Safety: Mixing Bleach with Other Cleaning Products Can Be Deadly
New Jersey Department of Health, Environmental and Occupational Health Surveillance Program · Government or regulator
Relied on for: That bleach combined with rubbing alcohol forms chloroform, with effects including dizziness, nausea, headaches and loss of consciousness. (states this directly)
Cleaning methods for stainless steel
British Stainless Steel Association · Trade or professional body
Relied on for: That hypochlorite bleaches require minimal contact time on stainless steel and thorough rinsing. (states this directly)