Skip to content
CleaningHQSearch

Adsorption of odour molecules

Smell molecules stick to surfaces rather than dissolving into them. It explains why two shirts worn identically smell differently — and it does not, yet, explain the open tub of bicarbonate.

In detail

An odour is a molecule small and light enough to leave a surface and reach a nose. Adsorption is what happens when one sticks to a solid surface instead: it is held at the boundary rather than dissolved into the bulk, and while it is held, it is not being smelled. The evidence here is about fabric, and it is direct. Shirts worn for the same intense session and then incubated smelled significantly less pleasant and more intense in polyester than in cotton, across every quality a trained panel assessed. Part of that is microbial. Part is physical, and the paper says so: cotton, being largely cellulose, has a high adsorbing capacity and holds volatile odour molecules, while polyester adsorbs them poorly and therefore releases more. The counter-intuitive consequence is that the fibre which holds odour smells less. What the evidence does not cover: how much odour an open dish of bicarbonate, charcoal or coffee grounds takes out of a fridge or a car. That question has no answer, because no authoritative source addresses adsorption as a general surface phenomenon — the evidence runs to fibre only.

Why

  • Cotton: A cellulose fibre, tolerant of hot water and alkaline detergents — and measurably degraded by chlorine bleach, which cuts the cellulose chains themselves.

    Cotton adsorbs odour molecules and releases fewer, so it smells less.

  • Polyester: A synthetic fibre that resists the chemistry which degrades cotton and wool, and is instead limited by heat — and it holds oily soil more stubbornly than either.

    Polyester adsorbs odour poorly, so more of it is released.

  • Fabric conditioner: A cationic coating deposited on the fibre at the end of the wash. It is not a cleaner, and the coating is why several fabrics say never to use it.
  • Milk stain: Protein and fat in water, and the reason a dried milk spill smells long after the mark has gone is that the protein is still there.
  • Tobacco residue: A sticky, yellow-brown tar film deposited everywhere at once. It is the reason a room smells after everything visible has been cleaned.
  • Faeces: A protein and biological soil where the hygiene question and the stain question have different answers, and the hygiene one comes first.
  • Fragrance: The part of a product that changes nothing about how it works, and the part most likely to be the reason somebody reacts to it.
  • Urine: Two problems in one: a visible mark that ordinary cleaning removes, and an odour that survives it. The second is why this stain has a reputation.

Sources for this page

Sources

  1. Microbial Odor Profile of Polyester and Cotton Clothes after a Fitness Session

    Applied and Environmental Microbiology, American Society for Microbiology, 2014 · Scientific literature

    Relied on for: That cotton, being largely cellulose, has a high adsorbing capacity and holds volatile odour molecules, whereas polyester adsorbs them poorly and so releases more of them, and that polyester shirts smelled significantly less pleasant and more intense than cotton after the same session. (states this directly)

Share this page