Skip to content
CleaningHQSearch

Polishing removes metal

Every polish takes a little of the object away. On solid metal that is a slow cost; on a plated one it is a countdown, and the end of it looks like more tarnish.

In detail

Most cleaning removes something sitting on a surface. Metal polishing removes part of the surface itself, and both conservation bodies say so plainly: each time you polish you take a little of the original away, and because tarnish is silver sulphide — a compound containing silver — removing the tarnish removes silver with it. Abrasive polishes make the cost much higher. Polishing creams, wadding and rouge sticks carry abrasive compounds and corrosive acids, remove far more surface than a cloth or a dip, leave fine scratches and gradually erase engraving. That is why the conservation answer is restraint rather than technique: keep tarnish removal to a minimum and use the mildest non-abrasive method that works. On a plated object the arithmetic changes completely. The silver is microns thick over a base metal, so polishing is not a slow tax but a countdown — and the failure has a cruel shape. Over-polishing removes the plating and exposes dull base metal, which can be mistaken for tarnish, inviting more polishing of the one place with nothing left to polish. The same logic reaches beyond silver.

Why

  • Sterling silver: 92.5% silver, and a rare material where the standard domestic treatment permanently removes some of the object. Tarnish contains silver, so cleaning it off costs silver.
  • Silver plate: A microns-thin layer of silver over a base metal. Everything that cleans sterling also thins the plating, and once it is through there is nothing underneath to polish.
  • Chrome plating: A thin decorative chromium layer over another metal. Hard and bright, but once the plating is breached the metal underneath corrodes and no cleaning reverses it.

    Failed chrome is damage rather than dirt, and this is the mechanism underneath that distinction.

  • Metal polish: A very fine abrasive with a mild chemical assist. Every use removes metal, which is why polishing a plated or antique item is a one-way decision.
  • Lacquered metal: Brass, copper or steel under a clear film applied to stop it tarnishing. Every metal polish sold for the metal underneath attacks the film instead.
  • Vehicle clear coat: A transparent film a fraction of a millimetre thick doing all the work. Everything that looks like a stain on car paint is usually an etch in this layer.

    The mechanism is not confined to metal, and the source states the paint case in the same terms.

  • Gold: Almost nothing attacks it, which is why the damage that does happen is nearly always done by the person cleaning it.
  • Chrome and brightwork trim: A plated layer that every polish makes thinner. Clean it gently once, then coat it so it needs polishing less often.

Sources for this page

Sources

  1. Conservation Information Sheet: Looking after silver

    Museum of Applied Arts & Sciences (MAAS), via Museums & Galleries of NSW · Trade or professional body

    Relied on for: That tarnish contains silver so a little metal is removed at every cleaning, that abrasive polishes carry corrosive acids and remove much more surface than a cloth or dip, and that over-polishing plated silver removes the plating and exposes base metal that can be mistaken for tarnish. (states this directly)

  2. Caring for your collections: Silver and plate

    The Institute of Conservation (Icon) · Trade or professional body

    Relied on for: That each polishing removes a little of the original surface, and that abrasive cleaners wear away silver and engraving over time and with repeated cleaning. (states this directly)

Share this page