What is this mark, residue or smell?
Start with what you can see or smell. Each group lists what it could be and how to tell them apart.
First, is it on the surface or in it?
This matters most on polished stone and glass. A mark that is damage will not clean off, and trying harder makes it worse.
Run a fingertip across the edge of the mark. Does the texture change?
No: probably on the surface
- Something arrived.
- Identify it, then clean it.
Yes: probably in the surface
- The surface was removed.
- Stop cleaning. It needs repair or cannot be reversed.
Then, what does it look like?
White, chalky or cloudy
- LimescaleDescale
Hard and chalky, and worst where water is heated or evaporates.
- Soap scum
A film on a shower screen. Forms where hard water meets true soap.
- Water marksDescale
A mineral film left where water dried instead of being wiped.
- Drinking glasses
Cloudy glasses: either a deposit or permanent etching.
- Road salt
A white tidemark on boots, carpet or car sills.
- EfflorescenceSteps
White patches on concrete paving, often mistaken for fading.
- Antiperspirant residue
White transfer on clothes, from the product itself.
- Grout hazeSteps
A dull film across new tiles, left behind after grouting.
- Etched or corroded glassDamage, not dirtSteps
Cloudiness that stays when glass is wet or wiped with acid. It is damage.
A dull patch on a polished surface
- Etching versus staining
Run a fingertip across the edge. If the texture changes it is probably etching, which needs re-polishing rather than cleaning.
- Etched or corroded glassDamage, not dirtSteps
Glass that stays cloudy whatever you clean it with.
- Water-borne film
Haze that appeared after cleaning rather than before it.
- Cleaning product residue
Left by the last clean, and it collects soil fast.
Black, grey or speckled
- MouldLiving growth
A living growth. Removing it does not deal with the moisture behind it.
- MildewLiving growth
Flat and powdery on damp fabric, grout and shower curtains.
- Soot
Carbon particles from burning. Lifted dry rather than dissolved.
- Skin oilDegrease
Darkens with age wherever people touch, and can feel tacky.
Green
- AlgaeLiving growth
A green film outdoors, in shade or on paving that does not drain.
- Moss and lichenLiving growth
Three different organisms, told apart by where they grow.
- VerdigrisCorrosion
Green corrosion on copper and brass.
Orange, brown or rusty
- Rust
A surface deposit cleans off. Active corrosion of the item does not.
- Iron staining from water
The water supply itself is carrying the stain.
- Tobacco residueSteps
A sticky yellow-brown film on everything in a room.
Yellowing
- Antiperspirant residue
Yellow underarm marks that built up in the fabric over months.
- Phenolic yellowing
A yellow patch the exact shape of a rug on the carpet.
Dark or rainbow marks on metal
Sticky or tacky
- Sticky plastic
Plastic that turns tacky again about a week after wiping.
- Label residue
Adhesive left behind by a label, turning grey with dirt.
- Uncured epoxy resinSteps
Resin that has not set. Handle it as a skin hazard first.
- Cured epoxy and resinSteps
Hard, set resin. Removing it is scraping, not cleaning.
- Super glueSteps
A hard, clear bead, often where something was repaired.
- Melted sugar or plastic on a hob
A hard or shiny patch on a hob, where sugar or plastic melted.
- Tobacco residueSteps
A sticky film all over a room where someone has smoked.
A smell you cannot place
- UrineClean, then disinfectSteps
An odour that survives after the visible mark has gone.
- Tobacco residueSteps
A room that still smells after everything visible is clean.
- Perspiration
Fabric smells, caused by bacteria feeding on sweat.
These are starting points, not an identification. If none of them fits, do not guess with a stronger product. Look up the material first.
Dirt or damage? Twelve things that look alike
Open the one that matches. Each gives a safe check first, then what to do and when to stop.
Cloudy glass: film or etching?
Drinking glasses have gone cloudy after the dishwasher.
Possibly a limescale film
- Check: Put a drop of vinegar on a cloudy patch. If it clears, it is probably a film.
- Confidence: several sources agree
- Then: Check salt and rinse aid, and descale the machine.
- Stop: If vinegar makes no difference, stop scrubbing.
Possibly etching
- Check: Look for a rainbow sheen. If vinegar changes nothing, it is probably etching.
- Confidence: several sources agree
- Then: It cannot be cleaned off. Use less detergent in soft water and a shorter cycle.
- Stop: Nothing removes it, so keep or replace the glass.
Sources for this check
- HELP! Our Glasses Are Cloudy!, University of Florida IFAS Extension
- How to clean cloudy glasses, Finish (Reckitt)
- Dishwasher leaves glasses cloudy, Bosch Home Appliances UK
- Owner's Manual: Dishwashers GSD4500, GSD4800, GE Appliances
White deposit: limescale or soap residue?
A white or grey film on a shower screen, tiles or taps.
Possibly limescale
- Check: Note where it is. Limescale forms where hard water dries, such as on shower nozzles.
- Confidence: limited evidence
- Then: Use the descaler your fitting's maker allows, tested first.
- Stop: Keep acids off marble, limestone and cement grout.
Possibly soap residue
- Check: Note where it is. Soap residue forms where true soap meets hard water.
- Confidence: limited evidence
- Then: Open it with warm water and a little vinegar solution on surfaces that allow acid.
- Stop: Keep vinegar off calcareous stone. It can dull or etch it.
Sources for this check
- Descaling your shower head, Hansgrohe
- Care & Cleaning of Natural Stone, Natural Stone Institute
- Cleaning Grout, Tile Council of North America (TCNA)
- Spot Solver: spot and spill removal procedures, The Carpet and Rug Institute (CRI)
- Handbook of Detergents (Surfactant Science Series), CRC Press / Taylor & Francis
Rust on stainless steel: stain or corrosion?
Orange or brown marks on a stainless steel sink or surface.
Probably shed steel particles rusting
- Check: Ask whether wire wool or a steel scourer was used. Do the marks wipe with a mild cream?
- Confidence: one good source
- Then: Use a mild non-scratching cream. Move to nylon pads and stop using steel wool.
- Stop: If a mark stays, oxalic acid is an option, but it is poisonous if swallowed.
Possibly pitting from chlorides
- Check: Look for small pits you can feel, after bleach or salt was left on the steel.
- Confidence: one good source
- Then: Stop bleach soaks and wash off salty food. Pits are damage, so they will not clean out.
- Stop: Do not use hydrochloric acid cleaners on stainless steel.
Sources for this check
- Care and Maintenance of Stainless Steel, British Stainless Steel Association, Stainless Steel Advisory Service
- Cleaning methods for stainless steel, British Stainless Steel Association
Dark spots: mould or a stain?
Black or grey spots on a wall, ceiling or sealant.
Possibly mould growth
- Check: Look for damp, a musty smell, condensation or a leak nearby.
- Confidence: several sources agree
- Then: Fix the moisture first, clean hard surfaces, and dry completely.
- Stop: Large areas are for professionals. UK guidance says so, and the US line is about 10 sq ft.
Possibly a stain or old damage
- Check: You find no damp, musty smell, condensation or leak.
- Confidence: limited evidence
- Then: Dead mould can still cause reactions, so clean it off rather than painting over it.
- Stop: If you cannot tell, treat it as mould. Bleach alone is not a removal method.
Sources for this check
- Understanding and addressing the health risks of damp and mould in the home — guidance for rented housing providers, UK Health Security Agency and Department for Levelling Up, Housing and Communities, GOV.UK
- Mold Cleanup in Your Home, United States Environmental Protection Agency (EPA)
- Mold and Moisture in Homes, Minnesota Department of Health
- A Brief Guide to Mold, Moisture, and Your Home, United States Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), Office of Air and Radiation
Yellow plastic: dirt or ageing?
A plastic item has turned yellow or discoloured.
Possibly surface soil
- Check: Wipe a hidden area with a cloth and mild detergent. Does colour come off on the cloth?
- Confidence: limited evidence
- Then: Continue gently with the same cloth, and rinse.
- Stop: Stop if the surface changes. Improper cleaning accelerates decay in plastics.
Possibly the plastic itself ageing
- Check: Look for tackiness, warping, crazing or brittleness, or a vinegar or camphor smell.
- Confidence: one good source
- Then: This is not dirt, and cleaning will not reverse it. Store it ventilated, not sealed.
- Stop: Once these signs appear, deterioration is irreversible.
Sources for this check
- Conserve O Gram 8/4: Care and Identification of Objects Made from Plastic, National Park Service, US Department of the Interior
Sticky surface: residue or breaking down?
A plastic or rubbery item has gone tacky.
Possibly plasticiser reaching the surface
- Check: Clean a small area. If the tackiness returns, the additive is migrating from within.
- Confidence: one good source
- Then: You can remove some, but it will keep returning.
- Stop: Do not keep cleaning harder. It will not fix the material.
Possibly detergent residue or spilled soil
- Check: Does it stay clean after one wipe and a good rinse?
- Confidence: limited evidence
- Then: Rinse with a clean damp cloth. Too much soap leaves residue that attracts dirt.
- Stop: On vehicle interiors, avoid degreasers and solvents, which can change how trim looks.
Sources for this check
- Conserve O Gram 8/4: Care and Identification of Objects Made from Plastic, National Park Service, US Department of the Interior
- Service Bulletin 06-00-89-029T: Interior Cleaning — Instrument Panel, Hard or Plastic Surfaces, Seats, Carpet, Leather, Vinyl, Fabric, General Motors LLC, published via NHTSA
Water marks: on the surface or in the finish?
Pale rings or spots on stone, wood or stainless steel.
Possibly a mineral mark on stone
- Check: A mark on polished stone that buffs away was on the surface.
- Confidence: one good source
- Then: The Natural Stone Institute buffs water spots with dry 0000 steel wool.
- Stop: Test first. Steel particles can shed and rust, so keep steel wool away from stainless steel.
Possibly etching in stone
- Check: It looks dull or rough even when dry, and came from something acidic.
- Confidence: one good source
- Then: This is not a cleaning problem. Contact a stone professional about re-polishing.
- Stop: Stop cleaning. More product makes it worse.
Possibly damage to a wood finish
- Check: Test the finish in a hidden spot. If white spirit soften it, stop.
- Confidence: one good source
- Then: On a sound finish, follow gentle wood cleaning. On anything old, ask a conservator.
- Stop: Do not attempt to clean a finish the test softens.
Sources for this check
- Care & Cleaning of Natural Stone, Natural Stone Institute
- Care and Maintenance of Stainless Steel, British Stainless Steel Association, Stainless Steel Advisory Service
- Conserve O Gram 7/1: Cleaning Wood Furniture, National Park Service, US Department of the Interior
Dark grout: stained or breaking down?
Grout lines have darkened, or look worn or crumbly.
Possibly staining
- Check: The grout is firm and whole, with colour change only.
- Confidence: one good source
- Then: Use an alkaline cleaner, not an acid. Cement grout is porous and absorbs stains.
- Stop: Acids attack cement, so keep them away from it.
Possibly grout attacked or worn
- Check: Grout is soft, sandy or missing, especially after acid products.
- Confidence: limited evidence
- Then: This is not dirt. Stop cleaning and ask a tiler about repair.
- Stop: Do not scrub at it. No cleaning method restores etched grout.
Sources for this check
- Cleaning Grout, Tile Council of North America (TCNA)
Carpet patch: stain or lost colour?
A patch of carpet has changed colour.
Possibly a removable stain
- Check: Blot with a white cloth and a tested cleaner. Colour moves onto the cloth.
- Confidence: several sources agree
- Then: Keep blotting from the edge inwards, rinse by blotting and do not scrub.
- Stop: Stop if nothing moves onto the cloth.
Possibly dye loss
- Check: Beige carpet turning red, yellow or orange after urine points to attacked dye.
- Confidence: several sources agree
- Then: Dye and fibre may be permanently damaged. Ask a professional about repair.
- Stop: Cleaning can make this more obvious, because the soil that hid it has gone.
Possibly browning on plant fibres
- Check: Yellow to brown marks after jute or cotton stayed wet and dried slowly.
- Confidence: one good source
- Then: Call a professional. The institute says not to try to fix browning yourself.
- Stop: Stop here. This is not a job for a household cleaner.
Sources for this check
- Cleaning and Maintenance, The Carpet and Rug Institute (CRI)
- Removing stains from wool, The Woolmark Company
- CRI Technical Bulletin: Pet Urine and Carpet, The Carpet and Rug Institute (CRI)
- Consumer Floor and Furnishings Care Information: carpet topics, Institute of Inspection, Cleaning and Restoration Certification (IICRC)
A smell that returns: where is the source?
A cleaned area smells fine, then the odour comes back.
Possibly urine still in the backing or padding
- Check: The smell returns with damp or humid weather.
- Confidence: several sources agree
- Then: Remove the source. Padding may need replacing.
- Stop: Fragranced products may only mask it.
Possibly mould beneath the surface
- Check: A musty smell, often with padding that stays wet while the pile feels dry.
- Confidence: one good source
- Then: Find the moisture. Surface cleaning cannot reach backing, padding or subfloor.
- Stop: Heat and humidity from cleaning can amplify odours.
Possibly smoke or spills inside upholstery
- Check: The smell comes from a cushion or seat, not the surface.
- Confidence: one good source
- Then: A professional may treat it, but cannot always tell if treatment reached the source.
- Stop: Cores may need replacing.
Sources for this check
- CRI Technical Bulletin: Pet Urine and Carpet, The Carpet and Rug Institute (CRI)
- Consumer Floor and Furnishings Care Information: carpet topics, Institute of Inspection, Cleaning and Restoration Certification (IICRC)
- How to Clean-Up Cat Urine, The Ohio State University College of Veterinary Medicine (Indoor Pet Initiative)
- Consumer Floor and Furnishings Care Information: upholstery, Institute of Inspection, Cleaning and Restoration Certification (IICRC)
Gets dirty faster: is it residue?
A surface looks grubby soon after you cleaned it.
Possibly detergent left behind
- Check: Carpet re-soils fast, or a hard surface is tacky or streaky after cleaning.
- Confidence: several sources agree
- Then: Rinse with clean water, by blotting on carpet, and use less product next time.
- Stop: On a wood floor, do not swap to vinegar. It can leave a sticky residue too.
Possibly soil you cannot see arriving
- Check: Dark lines at skirtings or under doors are soil filtered from the air.
- Confidence: one good source
- Then: This soil embeds deeply. Removal is professional and may be incomplete.
- Stop: Ask a professional rather than trying stronger products.
Sources for this check
- Consumer Floor and Furnishings Care Information: carpet topics, Institute of Inspection, Cleaning and Restoration Certification (IICRC)
- Service Bulletin 06-00-89-029T: Interior Cleaning — Instrument Panel, Hard or Plastic Surfaces, Seats, Carpet, Leather, Vinyl, Fabric, General Motors LLC, published via NHTSA
- How to Clean and Take Care of Your Wood Floors: Essential Tips for Homeowners, National Wood Flooring Association (NWFA)
It keeps coming back: what is feeding it?
The same mark or growth returns after cleaning.
Possibly moisture
- Check: Look for condensation, a leak or something that never fully dries.
- Confidence: several sources agree
- Then: Fix moisture first. Without that, mould can return within days.
- Stop: If the moisture comes from the building, cleaning alone will not hold.
Possibly stain rising from below
- Check: A carpet stain returns as the carpet dries.
- Confidence: one good source
- Then: That may be wicking: soil left deep in the pile rising to the tips as it dries.
- Stop: Cleaning cannot remove all embedded soil. Ask a professional if it persists.
Possibly a food source on the surface
- Check: Mould on a composite deck sits on pollen and dirt.
- Confidence: one good source
- Then: Remove the layer with warm soapy water and a soft brush.
- Stop: Do not use a wire brush.
Sources for this check
- Mold and Moisture in Homes, Minnesota Department of Health
- Removing Mold in Your Home, publication C 1047-2, University of Georgia Cooperative Extension
- Understanding and addressing the health risks of damp and mould in the home — guidance for rented housing providers, UK Health Security Agency and Department for Levelling Up, Housing and Communities, GOV.UK
- Consumer Floor and Furnishings Care Information: carpet topics, Institute of Inspection, Cleaning and Restoration Certification (IICRC)
- How to clean a Trex deck, Trex